What Does It Take to be the Best SEO Company in Canada?

What makes one SEO company better than another? It’s not just rankings or fancy reports … it’s how they approach strategy, communication, and long-term results. If you’re thinking about hiring an SEO partner, this article will help you know what to look for (and what to avoid).

Carissa Krause

Carissa Krause | Last updated June 27, 2025

A Canadian flag on a pole overlooks a turquoise lake surrounded by mountains and trees. Bold text across the image reads, "Great SEO Takes More" on a pink and red graphic background, highlighting the expertise of the best SEO company.

TL;DR – Here’s What to Look for in a Great SEO Company

  • Strategy over shortcuts: Real SEO takes time, planning, and long-term thinking.
  • Clear communication matters: You should always know what’s being done and why.
  • Customization is key: Avoid one-size-fits-all packages, because your business deserves better.
  • Ethics over gimmicks: The best SEO companies use white-hat tactics that protect your brand.
  • Results that align with your goals: Rankings are great, but meaningful conversions and growth matter more.

In a world where being seen online can make or break a business, 1st on the List continues to work diligently to be the best SEO company in Canada for our clients!

Since our inception in 1996, we’ve witnessed many web browsers come and go. We’ve also been there for every Google update. This experience helped us to continually hone our digital marketing strategies to become the best Canadian SEO company possible.

We are not just another SEO agency. Beyond simply achieving rankings, we value our relationships with clients and look to build trust through clear advice and strategies. After all, your success is our success:

  • 1st on the list has maintained client relationships for over 20 years, far exceeding the industry’s 24-month turnover norm.
  • The size of our SEO agency ensures personalized service with a broad skill set, avoiding the pitfalls of larger, less personal firms.
  • We are committed to transparency and campaign impact. We recommend SEO only if it truly benefits your business goals – if not, we’ll tell you straight up.

These are just a few reasons why our clients consider us the best Canadian SEO agency.

Please keep reading to discover how our dedication to SEO has led to long-term success for our clients and major accomplishments within our own businesses.

History of Our Canadian SEO Company

Did you know that we’re probably the oldest SEO agency in Canada? 1st on the List was started in 1996 by Chris Genge at a time before SEO was even coined as a term. Google didn’t exist then! This means that we have experienced every single algorithm update that Google has ever released. We know what we’re doing.

To set the stage as to where the technological world was at this time, enjoy these interesting throwback tech facts:

LIKE WHAT YOU’RE READING?

If these articles are helpful,
imagine what our team
can do for you!

BOOK A DISCOVERY CALL >

Let’s identify the quick wins you can easily apply to your website.
Keiran Griffiths
Managing Director

More Traffic. Leads. Business.

Chat With Me

More Traffic. Leads. Growth.

Chat With Me

  • DVDs had just come out and started making their way to Canada.
  • eBay just started their online auction and shopping website.
  • Internet Explorer was the main medium for using the World Wide Web.
  • Yahoo! was the #1 search engine.
  • Amazon was just a bookstore.

How It All Started

Starting in 1996 as a personal project to understand search engine rankings, Chris Genge created 1st on the List, which was officially founded in 1997.

Chris started applying his engineering skills to pioneer SEO techniques during the early days of online search. Back then, the process was so responsive that Chris could change a single keyword on a website and see almost immediate improvements in rankings for that keyword—a story he often shared.

Although started as a one-man operation, 1st on the List quickly grew due to the demand for these new-found services. It eventually led to the expansion of the team and a new office space. This foundation set the stage for becoming a pioneering SEO firm in Canada.

Sadly, Chris Genge passed away in 2021 after a battle with cancer. He left behind a legacy of innovation and dedication to excellence in search engine digital marketing. His vision continues to guide the company, striving to maintain the high standards Chris set in providing leading SEO services.

Timeline History of 1st on the List

Over the years, we’ve expanded our SEO services to meet the unique needs of our clients. Here’s a brief timeline outlining our efforts to become the best SEO company in Canada:

A timeline details the history of "1st on the List," a Canadian SEO company. Key events include its founding in 1997, various achievements from 1999 to 2024, and annual milestones like awards and management changes.

Now that you know what makes our Abbotsford SEO company one of the best, in the next section we lay out what makes us different from other search engine marketing agencies. To learn more about our SEO company or our services, please call us toll-free at 1-888-262-6687

Our Ethos Surrounding SEO

You’re probably wondering what makes our SEO agency different from the rest. Our team understands the ins and outs of SEO. SEO is more to us than just ranking online one time. It’s about growing our clients’ businesses using long-lasting, white-hat SEO methods that have been tried and true for literally decades.

Here’s how we stand out amongst the search marketing crowd:

Long-Lasting Results

At 1st on the List, we implement SEO strategies that keep your website doing well in search results over time, prioritizing sustainable growth over short-term gains.

Long-lasting SEO results for a business means:

  • More (and consistent) inquiries
  • Higher conversion rates
  • Sustained growth and revenue

Our lasting SEO methods lay a strong foundation for your business’s website, allowing it to maintain long-term success even through all of Google’s algorithm changes. WE adjust our SEO strategies as needed to help to drive growth, attract the right customers, and meet your long-term objectives.

Organic White Hat Strategies

1st on the List only uses fair and honest SEO strategies to improve your website’s search rankings. White-hat organic SEO strategies involve using ethical methods to improve a business’s search engine rankings. For a business owner, this means attracting more genuine visitors to your website without risking penalties from search engines.

An Example of Why Organic SEO Strategies Matter

In 2012, Google’s algorithm update targeted websites using underhanded tactics, like purchasing low-quality backlinks. This shift led to a surge in businesses reaching out for our help to remedy the consequences of either their own backlink purchasing decisions or the actions of disreputable SEO firms they’d previously hired.

Untangling this web of black-hat backlinks was a meticulous process, requiring significant effort to remove enough of them for Google to lift penalties. Even after clearing the penalties, these websites struggled to regain their rankings because they lacked genuine, quality content. They also lacked quality backlinks – a reminder of the role that legitimate, organic SEO strategies play in building and maintaining a strong, long-term online presence.

Practical Guidance & Advice

At 1st on the List, we give advice and outline plans that fit what your business needs. We get that every business has its own goals and story. We tailor our SEO strategies to fit your business’s specific dreams and hurdles. We ditch the cookie-cutter methods and dive deep into what your business needs to grow online. Our clients receive hands-on, actionable strategies customized to their specific business.

Our commitment to search engine optimization goes beyond just strategies for our clients. Let’s take a look at how we’ve put our SEO ethos into action.

We Built 3 of Our Own Online Companies With SEO

At 1st on the List, we don’t just optimize clients’ websites but also cultivate our businesses through SEO. When clients ask, “If you’re experts in SEO, do you use it to expand your own business?” we can proudly answer that we do exactly that! Unlike many competitors, we have concrete examples like 1st on the List, That’s Coffee, and Lifty Life — companies that have flourished due to our SEO strategies.

1. 1st on The List: SEO At The Core

1st on the List logo with 25 Years of Excellence

Simply put, we continually strive to be the best SEO company in Canada. Our approach sets us apart from many other SEO agencies because we don’t just apply SEO for our clients – we actively use it to grow our business ventures as well.

This hands-on experience gives us a practical understanding of what truly works in search marketing. While some SEO agencies might not see the direct results of their SEO efforts, we witness the growth firsthand. 1st on the List uses SEO to build brand power and consistent rankings year after year when other SEO companies come and go.

Our successes are tangible evidence—like the proof in the pudding—that SEO isn’t just theory for us. It’s a proven digital marketing strategy for ourselves and our clients.

2. That’s Coffee: 100% Organic SEO Marketing

That's Coffee color logo over an image of dark roast coffee beans and a cup of espresso.

Imagine growing a business where every single customer discovers you exclusively through SEO. For 10+ years, our online gourmet coffee store, That’s Coffee, has been a real example of what happens when you apply SEO strategies without spending a penny on other marketing avenues.

We launched That’s Coffee as a real-world SEO laboratory and wanted to demonstrate what could be achieved when SEO recommendations are fully implemented — not just theorized.

This e-commerce gourmet coffee store is now one of the top-ranking online coffee shops in the US and has become the largest drop-ship vendor for our supplier.

The SEO rankings are outstanding, and the business has grown entirely from people finding us through search engines. This means the cost to attract each new customer has been practically nothing.

3. Lifty Life Hospitality: 7-Figure Revenues from SEO

Snowy mountains and evergreen trees with ski gondolas moving above, set against a clear blue sky. The center features a green mountain logo and the text "LIFTY LIFE.

While the vacation rental industry battles high customer acquisition and marketing costs, Lifty Life Hospitality has turned the tables. By leveraging SEO, they’ve reduced acquisition to almost nothing compared to the industry standard of USD 6,000 per homeowner.

Our successful SEO-driven strategy has led to a top-ranking position in Canada for vacation rental websites, with minimal spend.

The results? Lifty Life grew to 7-figure revenues and acquired new customers in an industry with high CPAs.

With numerous keywords driving our organic traffic, our approach with Lifty Life has proven that SEO can be a huge advantage, achieving growth and profitability that outpaces the competition.

4. Beyond Our Own Companies: Our Small Businesses

At 1st on the List, our commitment to SEO extends beyond professional services for our clients. Our team members actively use their SEO expertise to grow their individual business ventures, giving us firsthand insight into the challenges and stakes involved in running a business. One of our multi-talented SEO experts uses his expertise to grow his music business. Another talented employee uses her skills to grow her virtual assistant operations.

This blend of personal and professional use of search engine optimization enriches our understanding and empathy toward the business owners we work with. We’re not just SEO consultants; we are fellow small business owners who face and overcome similar everyday challenges.

Building our own companies with SEO strategies showcases our expertise and commitment to real-world results. Find out more by calling toll-free 1-888-262-6687

Keep scrolling to learn how we’ve applied this experience to drive growth for 50+ Canadian companies, many of which are long-term clients.

SEO Case Studies Of Canadian Companies We Grew

This section highlights our client success stories with various Canadian businesses, showing how we helped them grow their online and offline businesses.

Case Study 1: Small City HVAC Company

Image for Family Plumbing and Heating showing a man with wrench working below a sink

Family Plumbing and Heating needed more online visibility, impacting their ability to attract new customers and expand their local business.

What We Did

We upgraded Family Plumbing and Heating’s Website Design to a search-engine-friendly WordPress platform. The website was re-designed for action-oriented results. Our Content Development team completely rewrote the content to better represent their services and incorporated SEO keywords. We also initiated a Local SEO plan focusing on specific service-related keywords in Regina, enhancing the company’s online visibility and lead generation.

Results Achieved

After implementing SEO strategies with 1st on the List, Family Plumbing saw a substantial rise in online visibility and customer inquiries. This led to increased service calls, allowing them to grow their team and enhance their offerings.

For detailed insights into the strategy, visit the case study HERE.

Case Study 2: Full-Service Concrete Company

General Concrete Ltd. aimed to expand its business and attract customers closer to its primary service regions in the Lower Mainland and Fraser Valley BC.

What We Did

We provided General Concrete Ltd. with a new SEO-friendly website design featuring updated content and a design focused on converting visitors to leads. The website showcases its services and customer satisfaction effectively, complemented by a Local SEO campaign targeting specific regions and services.

Results Achieved

The revamped online strategy led to a significant increase in quality leads and job requests, enabling General Concrete Ltd. to double its workforce to meet the growing demand. For more about how we supported this concrete service company’s growth, view the case study HERE.

These case studies are evidence of strong ROI from our SEO and web design strategies. However, in the next section, you’ll find the nitty-gritty statistics that show why we’re are considered to be one of the top SEO firms in Canada.

Statistics Support Our Efforts to Be the Best SEO Company in Canada

Now it’s time to dive into the proof. ‘Check the receipts’ as they would say. Through a blend of expertise, innovation, and dedication, we’ve achieved remarkable results that not only highlight our team’s capabilities but also showcase our role in our clients’ successes.

Diverse Client Success Stories

From Fortune 500 companies to ambitious startups, our search engine expertise has propelled businesses of all sizes to new heights of online visibility and success.

An Increase Of Inquiries With SEO

Take a look at this graphic showing our client’s SEO campaign’s journey to success: from boosting search impressions and clicks to a surge of new inquiries and job opportunities:

Search Engine Optimization Brought Thousands Of New Calls

Here’s another snapshot of the real results our SEO strategies delivered for a client: more visitors, a huge spike in search impressions, and thousands of new calls:

More Long-Term Client Results

Below are more SEO wins we’ve achieved for our clients in the past few years, from almost 5 million search visits for one client to increasing web traffic 5-fold for another.

Award-Winning SEO

Our commitment to superior SEO services that produce results has earned our SEO company prestigious awards and recognition from industry-leading SEO authorities. This includes recognitions from the below organizations, underscoring our position as a leader in the SEO domain​:

2019 and 2020 SEO and Best in Search Awards from TopSEOs, Clutch, and SEMFirms

Our digital marketing agency has been seen in platforms and publications where our expertise has been recognized, showcasing our influence and authority in the SEO industry for nearly three decades.

As featured In banner

All product names, logos, and brands are the property of their respective owners. All company, product and service names used in this website are for identification purposes only. Use of these names, logos, and brands does not imply endorsement.

Now that you’ve seen our successes – a big shout out to our clients past and present for being a part of our journey. Let’s look at how our award-winning SEO services can help your business grow.

Ongoing Training & Learning

At 1st on the List, our knowledge of SEO isn’t just based on over 25 years of experience—a wealth of industry-recognized certifications backs it.

Our Certifications

Each badge of certification is a stamp of quality, assuring you that your SEO is in the hands of professionals who not only talk the talk but walk the walk.

Training, Trade Shows & Speaking Opportunities

Our team actively participates in major SEO conferences across North America to gather insights and network with industry leaders. This way, we stay in the know about successful search marketing methods through multiple sectors. Then, we use this knowledge and tailor it to help our clients succeed.

Some of these conferences and trade shows include:

How Our SEO Company Can Help Grow Your Business

seo digital marketing services at 1st on the list

Most SEO agencies use an outdated cookie-cutter, A-B-C-D-E approach. This approach cannot be customized to each client and doesn’t produce the results that the clients hired them for. At 1st on the List, we approach every client and business as a new project with its own unique needs. We offer a completely customized approach that produces the best results for their organization. Here’s how:

Three website screens for Eagle Mapping display a mountain-themed layout with aerial forest imagery, text sections like "About Us" and “What We Do,” and navigation options, including "Services," "Contact," and "Request a Quote.
A visual of an SEO-Friendly website built by 1st on the List. Check out our WOW factor website design portfolio for more tailored strategies.

Pillar 1: Build A Website With SEO In Mind From the Beginning

We start with a solid SEO foundation to ensure your website is visible to your intended audience from the get-go. Beautiful websites full of imagery and little-to-no text are, well, beautiful, but in the eyes of SERPs, they typically don’t rank.

Building a website with SEO in mind from the start is crucial for a business owner because it lays the foundation for your site to be more visible to search engines. You could have the best-looking website for your industry and beyond, however, without quality content that supports your keywords, search engines have trouble indexing the pages.

Our web design team specializes in creating user-friendly WordPress websites, ensuring that people can easily find your business online when they search for what you offer.

Pillar 2: Craft Website Content That Is SEO Friendly from the Start

Our content engages readers and is designed to perform well in search rankings, drawing in your target audience.

Making your website’s content SEO-friendly means writing it in a way search engines can understand and like. This helps your website show up higher when people search for things related to what your brand offers.

It’s like using the right keywords so search engines can match your site to what people are looking for, bringing more visitors to your site. This early step is important for reaching more potential customers and leads online, and we’re here to get it started.

We improve your website’s credibility and visibility through strategic link-building, establishing it as a trusted resource.

Quality link-building services help your website get mentioned and linked to from other websites, acting as recommendations in the online world. For search engines, each link is like a positive vote for your site, making it appear more trustworthy and authoritative.

This is crucial for businesses because a website seen as authoritative by search engines will rank higher in search results, attracting more visitors and potential customers.

Pillar 4:  Receive Monthly Reports That Track Your Performance

For a small business owner, the reports you receive are the details that matter: how many visitors, where did they come from, how can we get them to convert, and how can we get more?

​​With regular detailed reports on your website’s performance, we continuously refine our strategies to keep your business growing. No need for excess numbers or data that you don’t quite need or that doesn’t quite tell you what the next steps should be.

Monthly analytics are key pieces of information, allowing you to adjust SEO efforts to help your business grow online. In the next section, our SEO professionals share their thoughts on how we strive to be the best SEO company in Canada.

Expert Quotes From the Top SEOs in Our Company

You’ve now seen how we work hard to become the best SEO company in Canada, let’s hear insights from our top SEO experts. Their experience highlights the strategic thinking that powers 1st on the List’s success.

 

FAQ About Top Canadian SEO Companies

While there are many excellent SEO companies in Canada, the best one for you will take the time to align with your values, work well with your team, and earn your trust with transparent advice and strategies. It’s about finding an SEO agency that takes the time to understand your business needs and crafts ethical, tailored strategies that lead to real, measurable outcomes. When you click well, your campaigns are more likely to thrive. A top SEO company will make sure you’re on the same page every step of the way, so you can understand and feel confident in the path to your business’s growth.

When scouting for the top contenders in SEO, there are several ways you can hone in on the best choices for your needs:

  1. Check Google Search Results: See which SEO companies rank high for SEO-related queries. High rankings often indicate effective SEO practices. Just search ‘top SEO company Canada’.
  2. Use Evaluation Tools: Platforms like Clutch, Manifest, and SEMRush can offer insights into company performance. However, use caution, as some listings are paid and could reflect a certain level of bias.
  3. Community Leaders: Look at top-ranking companies within your community if having a local, in-person connection matters to your business.
  4. Client Reviews: Once you’ve compiled a list of potential SEO partners, delve into their client reviews and testimonials. This can give you a feel for their reliability, customer service, and the success they’ve delivered for others.

As you explore, consider these Canadian SEO companies that excel at what they do and how they do it:

The Status Bureaulocated in Vancouver, British Columbia

BlueHat Marketinglocated in Mount Royal, Quebec

CAYK Marketing Inc. located in Calgary, Alberta

Search Engine People located in Pickering, Ontario

NAV43 located in Toronto, Ontario

To find the right SEO company for your business, start by reviewing their case studies and client testimonials to gauge their expertise and success rates. You should discuss their approach to SEO, how they plan to align it with your business objectives, and their method of reporting and communication. Compatibility in these areas is key to a successful partnership!

An SEO company in Canada focuses on optimizing your website to rank higher in search engine results pages (SERPs), increasing your online visibility to attract more targeted traffic. They work on improving your business’s website structure, content quality, keyword relevance, and backlink profile to enhance both user experience and search engine ranking.

Ask questions before hiring an SEO company, ask about their experience with businesses like yours, how they measure success, and their strategy for improving your search rankings. Ask about their successes, how they stay updated with SEO changes, and how they plan to understand your audience. Understanding their approach helps see if they’re the right fit for your business’s needs. 

The cost of SEO marketing services varies, depending on your business size, scope of the services, and the competition level. Here are some typical price ranges:

  • Automated Local SEO: $300-$500 per month for basic visibility improvements.
  • Small-Scale SEO: $1,500-$2,500 per month, suitable for small to medium-sized businesses (SMEs) aiming for comprehensive SEO strategies.
  • Comprehensive Local SEO: $3,000-$5,000 per month, designed for businesses targeting aggressive growth in local search rankings.
  • General SEO Budgets: Most companies invest between $500 and $10,000 per month, depending on their specific needs and goals.

Competitive industries such as legal services, healthcare, finance, and marketing agencies often face higher SEO costs due to intense competition. These types of business are closely watched and must meet Google’s EEAT requirements. It’s an investment in long-term growth, so it’s best to discuss your budget and what you hope to achieve with the SEO team.

You can tell if SEO is working by monitoring increases in your website’s traffic and how high you rank for targeted keywords. Your SEO firm should provide regular reports showing progress and areas for improvement.

Guarantees on rankings aren’t realistic, but a strong SEO company significantly boosts your chances. While no one can guarantee specific rankings, experienced SEO teams use strategies that have a proven track record of improving online visibility and driving more organic traffic to your site.

Wondering If Our Canadian SEO Company Is The Right Fit?

Every business is different, and so is every SEO strategy. Over the years, 1st on the List Promotion has successfully helped hundreds of companies become visible online with top-ranking results that last.

If you’re serious about improving your visibility and growing online, we’d love to learn more about your goals and share how we can help. Our Discovery Call is a no-pressure way to explore what working together could look like (here’s what to expect in that first chat).

Set up a chat by completing the form below, calling us toll-free at 1-888-262-6687, or connecting with us online.

Carissa Krause
Carissa Krause

Carissa Krause is a Digital Marketing and Project Specialist at 1st on the List. Over the last 13+ years she has worked in our Abbotsford office with clients on a wide range of projects that include areas like local SEO, project reporting, backlink profile review, content development, strategic planning, and more. Whatever the project may be Carissa focuses on achieving greater efficiencies and putting plans into action. When away from her desk you’ll likely find her drinking all the coffee while sitting on the floor driving cars with her three young boys.

Don’t miss out – get newest posts straight to your inbox!


Partner With Us. Get More Leads.

Stop trying to do it all on your own – reach out to our team and we can discuss marketing strategies that are best suited for your business!

[NO HASSLE, NO PRESSURE, NO WORRIES – JUST MEANINGFUL INSIGHTS]

Name*
Consent
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.